Sign in

Judge Mary C. Baumgarten

Hears cases at the Buffalo Immigration Court. Granted 0.3% of the 365 asylum claims decided in the last 12 months, against 6.8% across all courts.

Data through · Source: EOIR case data · How we calculate this

Asylum grant rate, last 12 months0.3%▼ 6.6 pts below all courts1 of 365 claims granted · October 2025 to September 2026
Five-year rate: 8.5% (FY 2022–2026)
  • Judge Mary C. Baumgarten0.3%
  • Buffalo court3.5%
  • All immigration courts6.8%
Asylum claims decided, 12 months
365

1 granted · October 2025 to September 2026

Five-year rate
8.5%

825 decided · FY 2022–2026

Cases closed, last 12 months
2,204

Through September 2026

Pending cases assigned
3,487

September 30, 2026

Asylum decisions

In the last 12 months (October 2025 to September 2026), Judge Mary C. Baumgarten granted 1 of 365 asylum claims decided on the merits, a grant rate of 0.3%. Judges at the Buffalo Immigration Court granted 3.5% over the same months. Across all immigration courts the rate was 6.8%.

Over five fiscal years, from October 2021 through September 2026, Judge Mary C. Baumgarten decided 825 asylum claims on the merits and granted 70, a grant rate of 8.5%. Judges at the Buffalo Immigration Court together granted 26.3%. Across all immigration courts the rate was 28.4%.

Among the 6 judges based at the Buffalo Immigration Court with 100 or more asylum decisions, Judge Mary C. Baumgarten’s grant rate is the 2nd lowest. Nationwide, the rate is higher than 25% of the 819 judges with that many decisions. The judge’s yearly grant rate fell from 19.4% in FY 2022 to 0.3% in FY 2026. People from Ecuador made up 15% of the claims the judge decided.

Share of asylum claims granted, of those granted or denied.
Show the numbers
Fiscal yearDecidedGrantedThis judgeBuffalo court
FY 202236719.4%44.1%
FY 2023521121.2%44.2%
FY 20241313526.7%35.0%
FY 2025241166.6%27.0%
FY 202636510.3%3.5%
All years825708.5%26.3%

A rate is printed only for 20 or more decisions.

A grant rate reflects the cases a judge is assigned as much as the judge: nationality, detention and whether people have a lawyer all differ from one docket to the next.

How cases ended

Removal proceedings Judge Mary C. Baumgarten closed from October 2025 to September 2026, by result. Changes of venue and transfers are left out.

  • Removal ordered87.6%1,923
  • Terminated or dismissed6.1%133
  • Voluntary departure5.0%110
  • Relief or protection granted0.5%11
  • Other0.9%19

666 of the 1,923 removal orders (34.6%) were issued in absentia, after the person did not appear at a hearing.

Nationalities

The most common nationalities among the asylum claims Judge Mary C. Baumgarten decided, as a share of all 825 decisions.

Cases with and without a lawyer

On September 30, 2026, 2,348 of the 3,487 pending cases assigned to Judge Mary C. Baumgarten (67.3%) had a lawyer or accredited representative. All courts: 50.6%.

Of the asylum claims decided on the merits by Judge Mary C. Baumgarten in FY 2022–2026, 10.4% were granted when the person had a lawyer and 2.1% when they did not.

Of the removal cases closed by Judge Mary C. Baumgarten from October 2025 to September 2026, 44.2% of those without a lawyer ended in an in-absentia removal order, against 12.0% of those with one.

With a lawyerWithout a lawyerAll courts, withAll courts, without
Asylum claims decided, FY 2022–2026634191377,17482,900
Share granted10.4%2.1%32.7%8.5%
Removal cases closed, 12 months9451,251325,450682,540
Share ended in absentia12.0%44.2%7.5%61.7%

Represented means a lawyer or accredited representative had filed a notice of appearance (Form E-28) by the decision date, or by the data date for a pending case. A rate is printed for 50 or more cases. People with a lawyer differ from those without in many ways, so the gap is not the lawyer’s doing alone.

Bond decisions

Judge Mary C. Baumgarten decided 144 bond requests from October 2025 to September 2026 and set a bond in 47.9% of them. Across all courts the share was 26.0%. The median bond set was $15,000, and half fell between $10,000 and $20,000. The median across all courts was $7,500.

This judgeAll courts
Bond requests decided14495,978
Share in which the judge set a bond47.9%26.0%
Median bond set$15,000$7,500
Middle half of bonds set$10,000 to $20,000$5,000 to $10,000

Bond requests a judge decided from October 2025 to September 2026. EOIR does not publish what each bond decision code means, so these figures report only whether the judge set an amount. Amounts are printed for 25 or more bonds set.

How often hearings are postponed

Of the 4,768 master and individual hearings on the calendar before Judge Mary C. Baumgarten from October 2025 to September 2026, 2,517 (52.8%) were reset to a later date. EOIR charges every reset to the respondent, DHS or the court. The court’s own reasons, such as a judge reassigned or on leave, docket management or no time to finish, account for 30.7% of hearings; across all courts, 39.0%.

  • Case decided41.8%1,991
  • Moved on to a merits hearing2.1%100
  • Moved to an earlier date3.4%160
  • Reset, charged to the court30.7%1,465
  • Reset, charged to the respondent21.1%1,006
  • Reset, charged to DHS1.0%46
Show the numbers
How the hearing endedHearingsThis judgeAll courts
Case decided1,99141.8%29.2%
Moved on to a merits hearing1002.1%8.8%
Moved to an earlier date1603.4%2.5%
Reset, charged to the court1,46530.7%39.0%
Reset, charged to the respondent1,00621.1%17.7%
Reset, charged to DHS461.0%2.8%
All hearings4,768

A case decided means the judge closed the case at or before the hearing. Moved on means a master calendar hearing sent the case to its merits hearing.

BIA appeals

From October 2023 to September 2026, the Board of Immigration Appeals ruled on 65 appeals of Judge Mary C. Baumgarten’s decisions and sent 4 (6.2%) back, by remanding the case or sustaining the appeal. Across all courts the Board sent back 12.6%.

An appeal sent back does not always mean the judge erred: the Board also remands for new evidence or a change in the law.

Motions to pretermit asylum

From October 2025 to September 2026, Judge Mary C. Baumgarten ruled on 639 DHS motions to pretermit asylum, asking the judge to deny an application without a full hearing, and granted 96.7%. Across all courts the share was 80.4%. Every court and judge.

Courts

Courts where Judge Mary C. Baumgarten decided asylum claims since October 2021, closed cases in the 12 months through September 2026, or has cases pending.

CourtCases closed, 12 monthsAsylum decisionsPending
Buffalo Immigration Court2,2027723,487
Pearsall Immigration Court100
Oakdale Immigration Court0500
Las Vegas Immigration Court030

On September 30, 2026, 2,604 hearings were on Judge Mary C. Baumgarten’s calendar for cases still pending.

Other judges at the Buffalo Immigration Court

JudgeAsylum decisionsFive-year rate
Brandi Lohr32223.9%
Brian Counihan1139.7%
Eric Schultz1786.2%
Christopher Staszak39n/a
Carrie C. Johnson-Papillo1,22716.0%
Aviva L. Poczter82439.6%
Steven J. Connelly31532.1%
Alexander Rubin49n/a
Dorothy A. Harbeck1,14552.7%
James M. McCarthy90538.3%
Ubaid ul-Haq11616.4%

Have a case before Judge Mary C. Baumgarten?

Immigration courts reschedule constantly, and hearings move earlier as well as later. Lexfill’s Court Watch checks every watched client daily and tells your team the day a hearing is scheduled, moved, or advanced.

Questions

What is Judge Mary C. Baumgarten’s asylum grant rate?

In the last 12 months (October 2025 to September 2026), Judge Mary C. Baumgarten granted 1 of the 365 asylum claims decided on the merits, a grant rate of 0.3%. The rate across all immigration courts over the same months was 6.8%. Over FY 2022–2026 the judge’s rate was 8.5%, against 28.4% nationwide.

How does Judge Mary C. Baumgarten compare with other judges at the Buffalo Immigration Court?

Judges at the Buffalo Immigration Court together granted 26.3% of the asylum claims they decided in the same period, against 8.5% for Judge Mary C. Baumgarten.

How does Judge Mary C. Baumgarten decide bond requests?

Judge Mary C. Baumgarten decided 144 bond requests from October 2025 to September 2026 and set a bond in 47.9% of them, against 26.0% across all courts. The median bond set was $15,000. EOIR does not publish what each bond decision code means, so this counts only whether the judge set an amount.

Does having a lawyer matter before Judge Mary C. Baumgarten?

Of the asylum claims Judge Mary C. Baumgarten decided on the merits in FY 2022–2026, 10.4% were granted when the person had a lawyer and 2.1% when they did not. People with a lawyer differ from those without in many ways, so the gap is not the lawyer's doing alone.

Cite this page

Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0: quote any figure or chart with credit to Lexfill and a link to this page. Downloads and key numbers.

Citation

Source and method

These figures are computed by Lexfill from the case data the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) publishes each month in its FOIA Library. This page reflects the release with data through September 30, 2026 and is rebuilt with each new release. Definitions, thresholds and known limits are on the methodology page.

EOIR’s records contain data-entry errors, and our calculations can contain mistakes too. Check a figure against the court record before you rely on it. If a number looks wrong, tell us and we will check it against the release.

Statistics describe past decisions across many different cases. They do not predict the outcome of any case and are not legal advice. Lexfill is not a law firm and is not affiliated with EOIR or the U.S. Department of Justice.